Since I did a review of the newer Wet n Wild cream/gel liner last month, I figured it would be helpful to compare to the the original. You can read all my thoughts on the On Edge Creme Liner here. The color I have to review today is #886 or Black. If I remember correctly, these run for $2-3 wherever, Wet n Wild products are sold.
To continue reading the review and see swatches/comparisons, click the link below.
Below are the comparison swatches. The On Edge Creme Liner from the Fergie collection is on the left, and the Mega Eyes Creme Liner is on the right. As you can see, both are opaque blacks. The main difference is the new edition has a more shiny finish, while the original is more matte.
Bottom Line: Great liner, works fabulously, just as black as any drugstore or high end black cream/gel liner. The downside is that it dries out too quickly. As mentioned above, try depoting it into a different container. If you found yourself buying the On Edge Creme Liner, you don't need this one as well. Both are good options though.